Lucknow: The Allahabad high court has strongly criticised the alleged misuse of the Goonda Act in Uttar Pradesh , saying cases before it suggest the state govt appears determined to use the stringent law as a tool of harassment.
Justice Subhash Vidyarthi of the Lucknow bench said the Goonda Act is a “very powerful” legislation and must be invoked with great caution, only in clear cases and for maintaining public order. The court made the observations while quashing the order of the Gonda district magistrate declaring Zahid Ali a “goonda” and externing him from the district for six months. The court also set aside the appellate order passed by the divisional commissioner upholding the DM’s decision.
The HC also took exception to the police report mentioning the case in which Ali had already been acquitted, observing that it indicated that an incorrect picture of the petitioner had been placed before the DM.
The court further noted that there was a gap of nearly six years between the 2020 criminal case and the 2026 order declaring Ali a goonda. The court said that mere involvement in a single criminal case of 2020 could not establish that Ali was a habitual offender or habitually committed or abetted offences.
It said no rational nexus could be established between the two. Relying on such material, the court said, would violate the principles of natural justice. The bench also refused to accept the beat information report as a valid basis for invoking the Goonda Act. No criminal case had been registered on the basis of the information, nor had Ali been given an opportunity of hearing in relation to it. The court also found that the Gonda commissioner had treated the acquitted case as a pending case against Ali, reflecting a failure to properly exercise discretion.